At 47 years old, Eve Thomson has carved a unique niche in the literary world—one that bridges the gap between crime fiction and legal reality. As a former lawyer turned crime writer, Thomson brings an insider's perspective to her novels, particularly her latest work, 'Smother'. Unlike the sensationalized portrayals that dominate television screens, Thomson's work delves into the often tedious yet psychologically taxing nature of actual legal proceedings in Australia. Her approach offers readers a more authentic glimpse into how the justice system operates, complete with its procedural nuances and human consequences.

Thomson's writing process is deliberately structured to immerse readers in the courtroom experience. At the end of each chapter in 'Smother', she includes scenes from cross-examinations or witness examinations, effectively allowing readers to engage with the material as if they were jurors themselves. This technique creates a layered narrative where each character's perspective unfolds gradually, culminating in a judge's ruling that provides closure before the next chapter begins. As Thomson explains, "At the end of each chapter in my book, Smother, I include a scene from a cross-examination, or an examination, of a witness. You get each character's and each witness's perspective, and then the judge's ruling at the end."
One of Thomson's primary motivations as a writer is to correct the misconceptions about courtroom proceedings that popular media, particularly American television series, have perpetuated. These shows often depict lawyers dramatically pacing the courtroom or banging on tables in front of judges—behaviors that would be unthinkable in Australian legal settings. "I suspect some misapprehensions have come about from American television series, with lawyers walking around the courtroom and banging on the table in front of the judge – that would never happen in Australia," Thomson asserts. This attention to authenticity reflects her deep respect for the legal process and her desire to educate readers about its true nature.
Thomson keenly observes that the length of legal processes often takes a significant psychological toll on those involved.
What sets Thomson's work apart in the crime genre is her focus on what she terms 'crime adjacent' stories. Rather than centering on traditional criminal cases, her novels often explore civil law matters where no actual crime has been committed. This allows her to examine how prolonged legal processes affect human psychology and shape people's reactions to events. "My novels are 'crime adjacent' in that often there's no actual crime committed but they're about a legal case," Thomson notes. This approach reveals the emotional toll that legal battles take on individuals, regardless of whether criminal charges are involved.
Thomson keenly observes that the length of legal processes often takes a significant psychological toll on those involved. What might seem like a straightforward case to an outsider can drag on for months or even years, creating immense stress and uncertainty for the parties concerned. "It's often the length of the process that takes its toll on individuals. It's hard to explain to them why it's taking so long to resolve what they see as a black-and-white matter," she reflects. This insight forms the emotional core of her work, highlighting how the machinery of justice can grind down even the most resilient individuals.
While Thomson strives for accuracy in her legal depictions, she acknowledges the challenges of making courtroom scenes both believable and entertaining. "I put a lot of work into trying to make those [scenes] correct and entertaining but it can be tricky to put forward a set of facts that hooks the reader but is also believable from a lawyer's perspective. So they're not going to be 100 per cent accurate," she admits. This balance between authenticity and narrative drive is what makes her writing compelling—educating readers while keeping them engaged in the story.
Thomson's dedication to realistic legal storytelling stems from her frustration with poorly researched novels. "Obviously, when I read crime novels I get frustrated if the legal side of things isn't right. The novels I love – including the non-crime ones – are those that you can see have been well-researched and you get that sense of truth," she states. This commitment to authenticity ensures that readers not only enjoy her stories but also gain a deeper understanding of how the legal system truly functions, far from the dramatic distortions of popular media.
